Goodfellas resides within the old Decatur Post Building, which was built in 1888. The fine cigar and emporium has been operational for 12 of the historic building’s 122 years. Originally opened and operated by Evan Allen in 1998, Goodfellas was sold to father Gary Allen in 2001 and eventually purchased by youngest son Nate in 2006. Nate is still the sole owner and operator of Goodfellas and continues the family tradition of providing a quality product with excellent personal service. While cigars are often thought of as a luxury item, the recent economic collapse has not slowed down his business. Nate attributes his success to a loyal customer base and his attention to providing the best shopping experience for anyone that walks through his doors. As Nate would say, “Goodfellas will always be an escape for the guys.”


160 North Merchant Street, Decatur, IL 62523

Monday-Thursday: 10:00 AM-6:00 PM
Friday: 10:00AM-7:00PM
Sunday: Closed



Back to Top ↑
  • Facebook